Posted by
Ray on Sunday, November 11, 2007 7:44:11 PM
I have yet to write about the war to date; however it is time to speak up and try to explain some hard cold facts. It has been six years since 9/11, five years since we went into Afghanistan and four years since entering Iraq. What started as a united fight against the terrorists that directly attacked the United States has broken down into a partisan fight on every issue, war related or not. The partisanship has become so prevalent that many cannot even agree upon whether we even want to win in Iraq or elsewhere. Since when did American’s want to be losers and what do these people believe will happen if we lose, surrender or retreat in Iraq? I do not accept that America started, or is the cause of the war on terror. Our presence in Iraq is a battle front, not “The War”. One cannot compare this War with WWII or Vietnam; this is a war against extremist ideology, not against a country or government. The media and “enlightened groups and individuals” want to remind us that we won WWII in a shorter period of time. My question to them would be to name a religious war that has only lasted 5 years, or 10, or 25. In most cases, religious wars last decades, generations, centuries, or millenniums. Ask the Northern Irish, Jews, and, yes, the Muslims. America and the civilized world (including the majority of Muslims) are fighting a religious war, regardless whether we identify it as such or not; because our enemy certainly does! This Jihad has existed in various forms since the Muslim Moorish invasion of Spain from 711-721A.D. The method of battle for this enemy has always been terrorism … forcing conversion, literally, at the tip of the sword. I will also note these incursions occurred many centuries prior to the Crusades.
Winning against terrorism means staying alive, minimizing changes in our life styles, and understanding there will be no surrender of the enemy. In fact who do you think would or could offer a truce or surrender? Who represents the enemy? Or for that matter, who exactly is the enemy? They have no recognizable borders, government or infrastructure. If we accepted their surrender; do you believe they and millions of other extremist would honor it? What would we do with the terrorists at Guantanamo Bay Naval Base? No other country will accept them, so would we ship them to Massachusetts or California and say you’re free now … maybe even give them US citizenship? It may sound absurd, but that is exactly what some are suggesting.
I’m not racist or anti-Muslim, but I am anti-radical Islamic terrorist. Only a small percentage of Muslims fall into this category, but that is still a very large number. Yes, there are other terrorist organizations out there that are not Islamic or even religion based. However, the greatest threat to the U.S, the West and modern civilization in general is from this group. We must understand that they have uncompromising beliefs that include reestablishing Islamic states under Sharia law, thus, restoring dominance of the Muslim world, rejection of western culture and modern ideas/technology, destruction of Israel, and expansion of Muslim belief and authority worldwide. To accomplish these goals, they are calling on all Muslims to rise up and fight. They are serious and steadfast in their beliefs and determination and therefore we must be as well. We were told from the beginning that this war would be long, yet after only 6 years we are saying lets get it over. If we left Iraq and Afghanistan today; the enemy is not going to stop trying to kill us and leave us alone? Remember, even pacifist countries like Spain and Malaysia have suffered attacks. Afghanistan and Iraq are just two current battlegrounds. A total victory for us in these countries will not end the war; however, a defeat will definitely strengthen our enemy. In the long-run, time should be on our side, as terrorism has never been sustainable without state support. However, if/when an Islamic terrorist group obtains weapons of mass destruction (WMD), this will redefine the entire equation. Undoubtedly, when this occurs, the terrorists will eagerly use them ... there will be no warning, negotiation, compassion or sympathy. They will use them in locations causing the greatest loss of life and damage possible; the age, gender or religion of their victims will not be a factor. This incident will impact the entire global lifestyle, immediately impacting every one of us. This is why the events in Pakistan are so concerning. The media is dwelling on the President and former Prime Minister’s power struggle, but the real danger, that both of them are most fearful of, is the serious threat of Islamic radicals taking over the country. A country with 50 or more nuclear weapons! Therefore, we are in a race against time requiring actions based on incomplete and imperfect intelligence, acceptance of mistakes by our leaders, a long term commitment by our government, and more importantly commitment from the American public.
In our battle against terrorism, the US has lost approximately 3900 military and 3000 civilians (on 9/11). Comparatively, we lost over 6,600 people on D-Day alone and approximately 48,000 (USA/CSA) in the 3 days of Gettysburg. Additionally, most people receiving Social Security today have stories about the sacrifices made on the home front during WWII. However, we have had few true sacrifices in the War on Terror other than minor inconveniences at airports and the non-intrusive surveillance of very selective people. Of course families with military members and employers of Reserve and National Guard troops have been affected, but in general, the US military is at war, not America. Unfortunately, there will be more loss of life and we will likely begin personally sacrificing much more than a few long lines and personal searches before this war is over.
OK, once again I have painted a dire picture; therefore, I must offer possible solutions and hope. There are no quick fixes, but the enemy of our enemy is education, prosperity and interaction/connectivity with the outside world, and a secret weapon … women. This requires both military and non military actions. Currently our enemies’ children are educated in hate and destruction, not acceptance of others; an acceptance we take for granted in the US. Our enemy preys on the poor, uneducated and disconnected. That is not to say that our enemies’ leaders are poor or uneducated … quite the opposite. In fact, some are from wealthy families and were educated at Western universities. Of course, these are not the ones who blow themselves up … these are the ones who “lead”, influencing the masses with hate and fear, and instructing others to blow themselves up. If we, and the rest of the civilized world, can communicate with these peoples, we can eventually change their thoughts and behaviors. Information, truth and time is on our side. Technology is making it very difficult for anyone in the world to remain completely ignorant and disconnected in the future. Educated and informed people will not follow these ideologies or sociopath leaders for long. The hard part is, who reaches these groups? How long will it take? Can we accept the losses and challenges in the interim time? This requires much more than a military answer. The military’s role is to protect, defend and contain the threats. The best way to minimize our losses is keeping the enemy on the defensive and restricting their ability to operate. This includes military and other government actions, i.e. preventing the funding of terrorism and disrupting their communications. The US military and government organizations are effectively trained and equipped to execute this part of the equation, but can not do it alone. Therefore, a key role will be for the US to support and help other countries contain and prevent the growth of radical Islam in their countries also. The harder part, and key to winning the war, is the reeducation and dissemination of positive information, otherwise known as changing the hearts and minds of potential enemy recruits. This will require the moderate and mainstream elements of the Muslim religion to demonstrate their rejection of violent extremism and get their message of acceptance and peaceful coexistence with other cultures, religions and technological advancements. The tactics of the extremist can clearly be used against them, as we are now seeing in Iraq. Violence and intimidation against the West and even other Muslims and a backward vision of the future, as demonstrate by the Taliban, do not sell well to people as they experience freedom of expression, information and movement. As we have seen after our liberation and begin educating women in Afghanistan, mothers undoubtedly have influence over the “hate and suicide” education their children receive and can be strong allies. As more people become connected to the modern world, these extremist ideas and views are exposed and rejected.
Once again, time should be on our side if we have the patience and commitment to allow the process to complete and we can prevent the use of WMDs. We can hope that the rest of the modern world will realize the real threat and help as well. Hopefully that isn’t too late. As the only current Super Power and the focus of our enemy’s efforts, the US must continue to lead the world against the enemy. We are the only nation that can do so. Unfortunately we are busy fighting amongst ourselves rather than leading the civilized world. That is why we must stand united again as a nation and fight militarily, politically, financially and culturally against the enemy, not amongst ourselves. This requires all Americans, not just our military or our government. We have other serious problems and challenges within, but nothing like the challenge to our way of life and even existence that this threat presents. We need real leaders, not self promoting piranha. It is time to tell the people we hired, our elected officials, to lead, stop bickering between parties and face the real threat as united Americans. If we don’t, and they don’t, which party is in power will not matter at all. We all need to get serious about fighting and winning this war; our enemy is. Remember, terrorism has never won a war, and will never win, unless the targeted group gives up.
Ray Ivie
Heath, TX